Comparison

BugHerd alternatives: an honest pricing comparison for freelancers and small agencies

BugHerd, Marker.io, Feedbucket, MarkUp.io, ruttl and PinDeck, compared on what you'd actually pay in a year, not just the sticker price.

Yearly cost of website feedback tools for a solo freelancer with three projects, from 36 dollars with PinDeck per-project billing to 948 dollars
Disclosure: I build PinDeck, one of the tools in this comparison. I've tried to be fair: every competitor price below comes from their own public pricing page, checked on 10 November 2026, and I've included the cases where PinDeck is not the best choice.

BugHerd is the name most people know in visual website feedback, and it's a good product. But its pricing is built for agencies with a steady flow of work. If you're a freelancer with a handful of client projects a year, or a small studio of three to five people, you may be paying for a lot of months you don't use.

So instead of another feature checklist, this comparison asks a simpler question: what would each tool actually cost you over a year, for the way you work?

The short version
  • Every tool here lets clients leave feedback for free. The real difference is how you pay.
  • All the alternatives charge monthly (or yearly in advance), whether or not you have client work that month.
  • PinDeck is the only one that also offers pay-per-project billing: $18 a year plus $6 to $20 per project.
  • BugHerd and Marker.io are stronger if you need integrations like Jira, video feedback or session replay.

The tools at a glance

Prices in USD, excluding tax, from each tool's public pricing page on 10 November 2026. "Entry plan" is the cheapest paid plan.

ToolEntry planTeam membersClientsHow it's addedFree trial
BugHerd$50/mo, or $500/yr5Free, unlimitedExtension or script7 days
Marker.io$59/mo, or $39/mo yearly3Free, unlimitedWidget or extension15 days
Feedbucket$49/mo2Free, unlimitedScript on your site14 days
MarkUp.io$79/mo (50 MarkUps)UnlimitedNot statedShare link14 days
ruttlFree (1 project), or $18 per user/moUp to 5 freeFreeShare linkFree plan
PinDeck$18/yr + $6–20 per project, or $20/mo2Free, unlimitedChrome extension30 days, no card

Three ways to pay for a feedback tool

Before comparing numbers, it helps to see that these tools use different pricing models. Which one suits you depends on how steady your client work is.

Per workspace

Flat monthly fee

BugHerd, Marker.io, Feedbucket. One price covers a set number of team members and projects. Great value if you always have work on. You pay the same in a quiet month.

Per seat or usage

Pay per user or per item

ruttl charges per user. MarkUp.io charges by the number of "MarkUps" per month. Costs grow with team size or volume.

Per project

Pay when you have a project

PinDeck's project-based option. A small yearly access fee, then a one-time payment for each client project, based on how long it runs. No work, no cost.

PinDeck's pricing, in full

Since the whole point of this post is pricing, here's exactly what PinDeck costs, so you can check my maths:

OptionPriceTeam membersStorage
TrialFree for 30 days, no card2200 MB
Project-based$18/year access, plus per project: $6 (3 months), $11 (6 months), $16 (9 months), $20 (12 months)2500 MB
Pro$20/month, or $194/year (save 19%)101 GB
Agency$53/month, or $494/year (save 22%)253 GB

All options include unlimited clients and unlimited projects, within your storage. The project-based access doesn't renew automatically, and you pay for each project once, when you create it. A typical first project of three months costs $18 + $6 = $24 for the whole year.

What you'd actually pay in a year

Sticker prices are misleading because every tool bundles different limits. So here are three realistic scenarios, each priced on the cheapest plan that actually fits. Where a tool only shows monthly pricing, I've multiplied by 12.

Scenario A: solo freelancer, 3 projects a year

One person, three client websites a year, each with about three months of reviews and revisions.

Honest caveat: if you only ever run one small project at a time, ruttl's free plan (1 project, 5 pages) could cost you nothing at all.

Scenario B: busy freelancer, 8 projects a year

Two people (you plus a part-time designer), eight projects a year, each around six months long.

Tool and planYearly cost
PinDeck, per project ($18 + 8 × $11)$106
PinDeck Pro, yearly$194
ruttl Pro, 2 users$432
Marker.io Starter, yearly$468
BugHerd Standard, yearly$500
Feedbucket Pro$588
MarkUp.io Pro 50$948

Scenario C: small agency, 5 people, ~15 projects a year

Five team members, around fifteen projects a year with up to twelve running at once. This is where plan limits start to matter.

Tool and planYearly costWhy this plan
PinDeck, per project$183$18 + 15 × $11. Watch the 500 MB storage.
PinDeck Pro, yearly$19410 members, 1 GB. Simpler at this volume.
BugHerd Standard, yearly$500Exactly 5 members, 10 GB
MarkUp.io Pro 50$948Unlimited users, 50 MarkUps a month
Feedbucket Business$1,068Pro only includes 2 members
ruttl Pro, 5 users$1,080$18 per user per month
Marker.io Team, yearly$1,788Starter caps at 10 projects

At this size the gap narrows in a different way: BugHerd and Marker.io include much more storage and a long list of integrations that a growing agency may genuinely need. More on that below.

Which PinDeck option is cheaper for you?

Per-project billing wins for occasional work, and a subscription wins once you're busy. Here's the break-even for your own numbers:

Project-based$73
Pro, yearly$194
Pro, monthly × 12$240
Cheapest for youProject-based
You'd save $121 a year compared with Pro yearly.

With six-month projects, the break-even is 16 projects a year. With three-month projects, it's 29. Below that, pay per project.

Features: where the alternatives are stronger

Price isn't everything. Here's where I'd honestly recommend something other than PinDeck:

  • You live in Jira, Asana or Linear. BugHerd, Marker.io and Feedbucket all integrate with popular project management tools. PinDeck keeps feedback on its own board and doesn't offer those integrations today.
  • You need video or technical debugging. BugHerd supports video feedback. Marker.io's Team plan adds session replay and console logs, and Feedbucket's Business plan includes console logs. That's valuable for complex web apps.
  • Your clients won't install anything. Feedbucket and Marker.io offer a widget you add to the site, so clients just click a button. PinDeck uses a Chrome extension: no code on the client's website, but clients need Chrome or a Chromium browser like Edge or Brave.
  • You review PDFs, images and videos, not just websites. MarkUp.io is built for reviewing many content types, and BugHerd also handles Figma, PDF and image feedback.
  • You need lots of storage or enterprise features. BugHerd starts at 10 GB. PinDeck ranges from 500 MB to 3 GB. SSO and SLAs are only on the alternatives' higher tiers.
  • You want a long track record. BugHerd and Marker.io have been around for years. PinDeck is new, built and supported by one developer in Malaysia.

Where PinDeck fits best

And here's where PinDeck is the better fit:

  • Your client work comes in waves. Pay per project and add the cost to your quote. A three-month project costs $6. No bill in quiet months.
  • You're a small team on a tight budget. Pro includes 10 members for $194 a year, less than half of BugHerd's entry plan, which includes 5.
  • You want clients to sign off. Feedback moves through To Do, In Progress, Review and Closed, and the client closes each item once they've checked the fix.
  • You want no code on client sites. The extension works on live, staging and password-protected sites without touching the site's code.
  • You want a long trial. 30 days without a card, compared with 7 to 15 days for the others.

The honest verdict

Choose BugHerd or Marker.ioif you're an established agency with constant work, tight project-management integrations, or complex web apps that need video, console logs or session replay.
Choose Feedbucketif your clients won't install anything and you're happy adding a script to each site.
Choose MarkUp.ioif you mostly review PDFs, images and videos rather than live websites.
Choose ruttl's free planif you only ever have one small project at a time and need it to cost nothing.
Choose PinDeckif you're a freelancer or small agency, your projects come and go, and you'd rather pay per project than every month.

Whichever you pick, try it on a real client project first. Every tool here has a free trial or free plan, and an hour with an actual client tells you more than any comparison table, including this one.

If you'd like to try PinDeck, the 30-day trial needs no card, and your clients join free.

Prices change. Everything above was checked on each tool's public pricing page on 10 November 2026, in USD and excluding tax. If you spot something out of date, email [email protected] and I'll correct it.

Sources

  1. BugHerd pricing
  2. Marker.io pricing
  3. Feedbucket pricing
  4. MarkUp.io pricing
  5. ruttl pricing
  6. PinDeck pricing